Young Managers Perform the Best and Here's Why

Joe Weinlick
Posted by


Many people believe that older managers make better leaders because they have more experience in their industries. However, a recent Harvard study shows that young managers bring a lot to the table — elevation to a managerial position at a young age only happens with the highest achievers. Placing young managers into key roles within an organization comes with many benefits.

Technologically Savvy

One of the obvious benefits of employing young managers comes in their comfort with modern technology. Younger generations grew up with the Internet, cellphones and social media, so their members often naturally have more knowledge than their veteran counterparts who've had to adapt to changing technology over the years. Young managers can help their teams connect with customers and other businesses through online communications and find innovative ways to enhance company branding and marketing.

Open to Change

Young managers haven't worked long enough to be stuck in their ways, making them more flexible and open to change. Lack of formal experience fosters a stronger sense of optimism, no matter the difficulty. Younger leaders aren't afraid to get behind challenging new projects that require adaptation.

Enthusiastic

Young managers possess an innate enthusiasm that's highly beneficial to the workplace dynamic. While veterans can become tired or burned out after years of service, young workers can bring fresh energy and focus to the table, which improves morale across the board. Letting young managers make suggestions, lead teams and help with motivational programs injects positive energy into the work atmosphere while inspiring others.

Receptive

Older managers tend to be less receptive to feedback after years of perfecting their own formula. Young managers, on the other hand, are hungry for feedback, both positive and negative, to help them cultivate their management style. In addition to wanting feedback, young managers are also more willing to implement that feedback into effective changes.

Results Focused

Because of a strong need to prove themselves, young managers tend to be results-oriented and hungry for achievement. This makes younger leaders more apt to put lots of hard work and energy into accomplishing concrete objectives, while a more seasoned veteran may fall back on tried and true formulas to get by and remain complacent.

Goal Oriented

Younger leaders often show more willingness to set ambitious goals than their older counterparts. More seasoned workers tend to set more mediocre goals in order to avoid difficulties and possible failure. By contrast, many young managers love lofty goals and inspire their teams to work together to achieve them.

At some point, every organization will be faced with the task of replacing long-term managers and executives with younger leaders. While there young managers face many obstacles and challenges in proving themselves and gaining trust, they also bring diversity, enthusiasm and fresh perspective where it's most needed.


Photo courtesy of stockimages at FreeDigitalPhotos.net

 

Comment

Become a member to take advantage of more features, like commenting and voting.

  • Mike F.
    Mike F.

    I totally find this not to be true. All INDIVIDUALS have something to bring to the table

  • Susan C.
    Susan C.

    Wow. Ageism rears it's ugly head. A little balance here please!

  • Marty Wendt
    Marty Wendt

    Wow! Nice blanket statement. Define young...so enthusiasm is replacing knowledge and experience that would benefit your team. I can only imagine if you replaced Young/Older with White/Black or Man/Woman...ageism is alive and well as we all know.

  • DAVID R.
    DAVID R.

    Joe, While it's true that energy, drive, and fresh ideas are essential qualities for success and advancement, judgement and wisdom are what builds trust. And without trust, my friend, you're going to find yourself "sabotaged" by "office politics" and "threatened" co-workers. I'm using quotation marks because I've heard ambitious but unqualified junior associates use these words as excuses to explain their failure to inspire respect and collaboration among people of diverse backgrounds, skills and yes, ages. By the way, when I hear people of a certain generation talk about "growing up with the Internet," I have to smile. The generation you're slagging for being resistant to change are the ones who built the digital infrastructure that today no one can live without-- or afford to ignore. Good thing too, because one day you'll be able unearth this post and hopefully experience a pang of regret for publishing content that reveals inexperience and a staggering lack of tact, not to mention factual support. But you'll learn. Trust me.

  • William A.
    William A.

    Better to simply evaluate the management candidate on their merits rather than age. Stereotyping based on age could lead to discrimination.

  • Nancy Anderson
    Nancy Anderson

    @Jim D so sorry you feel this way. Older workers have been answering to younger workers forever! Just because you are older doesn't mean that you have the knowledge or aptitude to be in charge. The younger generation is not much different that we were when we were young. The difference is that, back then, you could get a position with a company (hospital) and stay there for your entire career. That is definitely not the norm today. From personal experience, I answered to countless younger men/women during my military career. Very seldom did I answer to an officer who was older than me. So it's not really all about age. Just my two cents worth.

  • Jim D.
    Jim D.

    I have no idea who Bealeaves this BS. There are cases but it is rare. I am almost 60 yeas old. I own several companyies. I have in the past placed younger folks into high positions and each time and In my case I am say Each and every time it caused the employee to become useless. A younger person often as the Nursing person put it cannot take crticisum very well. In fact they can not take it at all in more cases than not. I have ran companys since I was very young. I think the reason I could get away with it was I looked much older than I was and only a very few folks new my age. All the reasons listed in the article are in fact to some extent true but also some of them are also just flat out SciFi and or some kind of wishfull thinking. The study it mentions means nothing to me. I have seen so many studies that do not take many factors into account. I am saying this study is in part wrong in most cases as it is clearly not covering all issues. you can do what is called lie with statistics using the same tacktics. How many of you WANT a very young captain on your next flight??? I certainly do not. The older they look the better I feel and i am not the only person to feel that way. Same with MDs. I want the guy like John below. 1 factor that i feel contributs most to the problem of young folks in high responsability positions not working out well is casued by schools giving a passing grade for showing up at all but not based on performance. So the students beleave it is OK to get things wrong. Do you want that for your next MD for you or your child when you or that child is very very ill. I do not and I know most of you do not. And what also was not covered is the resentment by many of the older folks answering to someone that they know has less knowlage. I for one am OK with this.in some cases. But only in some cases and I know I again am not alone here. IF a younger person is exceptional then they will get my respect and I will have no problem working under them. None. But that is very rare with the exception of some of the high tech companies. I can back up everything I say with many many examples but have already made this way to long. However the foolishness of the article in my opinion regired eather a short " This is compleat BS " Or an partial explanation along with this is BS. Jimmy

  • Elizabeth G.
    Elizabeth G.

    ok....teach nursing and lots of youthful folks CANNOT take criticism and take stuff personally. NO. Young people are in some ways better at tech...more open to it but not better per se.

  • Nancy Anderson
    Nancy Anderson

    @Clayton thanks for your comment. John is absolutely right when it comes to leadership - that it's not age but experience, skills, character and work ethic that can drive us. However, if you are job seeking right now you would see that age truly does play a factor - especially when you are 55+ sitting across the table at an interview with a 24 yr old hiring manager. Sure can make you stop and rethink your priorities. However, it was great to hear that both you and your junior team member were able to learn from each other. That is a total win-win situation.

  • Clayton Cutbush
    Clayton Cutbush

    I agree with the posting to a degree, but also think it is more in tune with what John commented on with the first response to this article. The age is not the important factor. The work ethic and characteristics drive that ability to lead…that’s important. Young or old, we are successful based on getting a team to work cohesively.

    I believe the age and experience lends itself to a wisdom of knowing that you don’t know everything and relying on the team. One of my greatest work experiences I have had was working with (mentoring) a junior team member. We both learned a lot. We both accomplished a lot.

    My two cents :)

  • Gupchand B.
    Gupchand B.

    We are experiencing this same PROBLEM in the HealthCare arena. Two young Helpdesk tech, was asked to over see a bunch of 30 techs, right away, favoritisms, kicked right in, they micro managed the senior techs, even go so far to clean up, as if they are taken revenge for all those who took advantage of them. It got too childish, and having young manager like them degraded to idea of allowing young people to manage? Once you know your job, there is no need to baby sit anyone? especially if you hired us for work and there is a slow down, cuz you have no work for us, Don't get nasty or micro manage?. Wrong is Wrong, and having these clods to manage without any sense of Managing people was a sick and insulting moment for us all. It is a sad time for having young people manage.

  • Nancy Anderson
    Nancy Anderson

    @Angela great comment! Totally agree. We need young leaders in every industry because, well, after all, they will be our leaders in the future. But they need to realize that, in order to make it work for them, they need the more mature worker because of everything that we bring to the table.

  • ANGELA S.
    ANGELA S.

    Well said Harold and John! I've been in the secretarial field for over 30 years before "technology" became the "it" in the workplace. Everything I learned about technology I learned on the job or taking classes through my employer. So please don't insinuate that I don't want to learn! I thrive to learn more. It's a given these days, but don't dismiss my age (I'm 56) and experience because some study says I am stuck in my ways or I don't want to learn! The way I see it, yes, there are a lot of young people who are good at what they do and have learned, but there are just as many (in my opinion and what I've seen) who feel entitled and want the pay without the work!

  • Margie R.
    Margie R.

    Over all the years of working knowledge you grow.

  • John Ganahl
    John Ganahl

    I am one of those "experienced" managers referenced in this opinion article, but don't mistake my disagreement as a "disgruntled old man seeing the writing on the wall". If so, you would miss a valid point. It isn't AGE that defines the characteristics of good leadership. It's the leader themselves. Yes. I was "that guy" 40 years ago and I am STILL "that guy" today. I still have the same internal drive and desire to accomplish I had when my hair was dark. Certainly, there are technologies that have passed me by but true leadership is more about leading, about knowing the people around you, knowing THEIR capabilities and allowing THEM to grow. Leadership is far beyond the simplified pablum offered up in your opinion. Think back to when YOU were 25 and what kind of leader inspired you!

Jobs to Watch